Thursday, December 10, 2009

"Scripts pry open hidden worlds"

A recent piece in Variety:
Some screenplays make an impression by finding drama -- or comedy, for that matter -- in the everyday, or at least something that looks like it. "Ordinary People" and "Kramer vs. Kramer" won Oscars portraying fairly familiar American middle class lives. But other scripts invite the audience on a journey into hidden, hermetic worlds familiar only to insiders.

The article features the Coens (A Serious Man), Jason Reitman (Up in the Air), and Mark Boal (The Hurt Locker):

Then there are ways of hooking the aud. Joel Coen points out, "It's a hallmark of anthropological studies that the first thing they do is talk about societies that are foreign to the reader in terms of things that everyone can identify with, and then they reveal things that are weird and specific to the group. People like that."

----

The pic opens with Bingham (played by George Clooney) in an office, so the audience sees him in a familiar setting before they see him in an airport. But Reitman, who shares a writing credit with Sheldon Turner and directed the movie, notes the opening is hardly more comfortable for being in a familiar place.

"I'm actually starting the movie in the place where you'd be most uncomfortable, in the midst of a firing situation. From there, in contrast to that, I'm now taking Airworld and making it your comfort zone."

----

"The Hurt Locker" scribe Mark Boal's travel experience was less relaxing. He journeyed to Iraq as a journalist and rode along with the Army's Explosive Ordnance Disposal Squad. Boal doubts he could have written the story without that firsthand experience but emphasizes, "It's not a transcription of the experience. That would probably be a little more boring than the movie. "
Think of all the great movies that explore a specific subculture - from Witness (Amish) to Bring It On (cheerleaders) to The Whaler Rider (Maori). But for those stories to be successful, they have to be able to widen the experience of the characters:
Ultimately it's the universality of a story that makes it resonate with auds, even when the setting is as offbeat as Air World or Baghdad. Ethan Cohen recounts, "I remember a Catholic guy who said (his community) was exactly the same shit, and an Asian-American guy who said it was the exact same thing in Houston."
I saw A Serious Man recently in a theater that was comprised by perhaps 50% older Jews. And they laughed and laughed, especially at the small details of Jewish life in America's suburbs in the lates 60s. But by the end, I think everyone could relate to the Protagonist, everything about him relativized by his Job-like life-experience because every one of us has been crapped on in our lives.

How about you? What are your favorite subculture movies?

8 comments:

kyle said...

did you just group BRING IT ON with WITNESS and WHALE RIDER...? brilliant. it's like Oscar meets Razzie.

The_High_Dweller said...

I'm going to say the upcoming "Passengers" by Jon Spaihts... since this a screenwriting blog, I'm thinking of scripts that create an atmosphere.

Spaihts' script is undeniably brilliant, breathtaking, and beautiful. It's in a realm of its own.

Jeff said...

Just watched CHOKE last night with Sam Rockwell. The subculture of the sex addict. What an great film, had a blast watching it, even though it is quite sad, ultimately.

305Writer said...

I going to have to go with "Fight Club".

This is your life and it's ending one minute at a time.~Fight Club

Tom said...

Subculture movies are tricky because unless you really know your subject, you’ll alienate your target audience.

My favorites are espionage, military and crime movies. At the same time, some of the worst movies I’ve seen dealt with those subjects; because they were generally written by someone with no street cred in the subculture.

Two films I’ve seen in the last couple of years that are standouts for me are Traitor and The Kingdom. When I looked into the writing more closely, I discovered that in both cases the writers had significant consultation on the ins and outs of espionage and counterterrorism operations. Both were good films, but for me they were great because of the realism (and banality) they portrayed about those particular subcultures.

On the flip side, films like the Bourne or James Bond series are great fun because they go beyond stretching the limits of reality. When they’ve failed (Bond) it was because they tried to bring the story into the real world.

305Writer said...

This is some great insight on where to take your story.

Scott, with this way of looking at the journey you hero takes,I'm looking back at some of the movies I love,when the antagonist is in his own element, he's pretty damn tough, but when you take him out, he seems to lose his mojo.

The opposite seems to be with the hero, he seems weak or lacking in his world, but when called to action, he gets stronger as he makes his way to this new world.

Jeff said...

305 Writer mentioned Fight Club right after I tossed out Choke.

Is it safe to assume we should all read more Palahniuk?

Scott said...

@305writer who said: "Scott, with this way of looking at the journey you hero takes,I'm looking back at some of the movies I love,when the antagonist is in his own element, he's pretty damn tough, but when you take him out, he seems to lose his mojo.

The opposite seems to be with the hero, he seems weak or lacking in his world, but when called to action, he gets stronger as he makes his way to this new world."


From the paradigm of The Hero's Journey, that is precisely right. In their Ordinary World, they are unrealized potential, a reflection of their Disunity with their core essence suppressed, repressed, ignored. It takes their shift into the Extraordinary World where their defenses get broken down (Deconstruction) that they can build themselves up (Reconstruction) based upon their core essence, that authentic part of their self.

By extension, this enables the Protagonist to meet the Nemesis on a more level playing field, and if the story isn't a tragedy, the P defeats the N.

Good insight, 305writer. Glad the light bulb went on for you!