Blog

THE SCREENWRITING BLOG OF THE BLACK LIST

Mystery Man news

I just received this email:

Hello, my name is Rebekah. I was “Mystery Man’s” administrative assistant for a number of years. Unfortunately, he passed away not long ago. I’m terribly sorry.

He made it his express wish not to reveal his identity.

Before he passed away, he had completed roughly 2/3 of his screenwriting book, and I am partnering with a couple of writers to finish the book using bits from his various articles. I will follow-up with one more e-mail advising how his fans can download his free screenwriting book. I really have no idea yet as to when it will be available.

Again, I’m very sorry to bring you this news, and if you could assist us in getting the word out, we would greatly appreciate it.

I emailed Rebekah back. She confirmed that Mystery Man had, indeed, passed away. I can only assume this is true. If so, it’s awful news.

I’ll be posting things re Mystery Man over the weekend. Let’s start with a Q&A MM did here on GITS on November 12, 2009:

You know him (but not really), you love him (even though he is a mystery) — it’s Mystery Man (on Film). MM agreed to do a Q&A. Without further ado, here he is!

SM: First the handle: Mystery Man on Film. If I were to hazard a guess as to your real identity, which would be closer: William Goldman or Donald Kaufman from Adaptation?

MM: Oh come now, Scott, haven’t you figured me out yet? Hehehe You should know that both of those men are too insecure for my tastes. I love a confident, stylish, witty writer. (If you don’t feel confident, just just fake it. Insecurities are for schmucks.) Give me men like Marcello Mastroianni. He’s just an actor, I know, but he played a writer in La Notte. He was cool, confident, and oh-so-suave. Plus, he looked damn good in a suit. Who said writers have to dress like derelicts? What’s wrong with a writer being stylish? Different? Memorable? Entertaining? I say be better than who you are. I say become the icon you’ve always admired. I say create that persona and live up to it. That thing Shakespeare wrote, “To thine own self be true,” is such bullshit. Hehehe

SM: Okay, so way back when you started your original MMOF blog, as you cranked up your Commodore 128 computer, what exactly were you hoping to accomplish?

MM: If I take the time to seriously consider the craft and write an article about it, I can verbalize those thoughts more confidently in meetings. Some of these people in the industry are AMAZING. You have to seriously bring your A Game to the table. Beyond that, I enjoy rocking the boat.

SM: I read where The Unknown Screenwriter was an inspiration to you when you first started blogging. What other screenwriting bloggers are in your MMOF Hall of Fame?

MM: Well, I first began on TriggerStreet. I love writing script reviews. Then Unk was my inspiration to blog. So blame him. To this day, I still love his series on the The Transformational Character Arc. I’d put Go Into the Story on that pedestal worthy of daily visits. People used to complain about me being a prolific blogger. You’re a frickin’ machine! Of course, I read John August, Billy Mernit, Bill Martell, and Tedd & Terry’s articles. Danny Stack is great. He had a fabulous series on The Professional Screenwriter, which I highlighted here. Also, to this day, I love what Julie Gray wrote on theme & the entertaining question. Anytime someone sends me an e-mail about theme, I just tell them to read Julie’s article. I still love what Joshua James wrote on the Emotional Logic of Characters or his great formula of WHAT plus WHY equals WHO. And I love MaryAn Batchellor’s “Purpose of Battle Speeches” (here & here).

Script Mag has great articles on their website and podcasts, too. They just finished a 3-part podcast series on “Your Screenwriting Career in Today’s Market” (part one, part two, & part three, which you MUST take the time to hear. I also have to mention Ray Morton. I loved his article called Fouteen Scripts I Never Need to Read Again (Ever) and “How Not to Annoy the Reader” (Part One& Part Two).

For my blog, though, I wanted to showcase not just screenwriters but also the film bloggers because there is so much to be learned from them. Consider Film Studies for Free and, say, their latest collection of scholarly links on the art of close ups. Close ups, man! Unbelievable. Consider Jim Emerson’s fantastic Opening Shots Project. Consider David Bordwell and, for example, his free excerpts from his book, Film Art. The man’s a wonderful film scholar. Screenwriters should listen to him. I love – LOVE – Bordwell’s .pdf on The Man Who Knew Too Much. I also have a real thing for the mind of Matt Zoller Seitz and his video essays, like Zen Pulp. How about Girish Shambu, my all-time favorite blogger. He had a post on Poetics in Cinema that – I kid you not – forever altered my perspective on storytelling.

If that’s not enough, I recently posted my own 101 Best Articles.

SM: After all these years, you’ve quit blogging in order to take up Tweeting. What do you Tweet, why do you Tweet, and for whom do you Tweet?

MM: I knew the bottom was going to drop in Hollywood and I wanted to carefully follow the stories. When Anne Thompson started writing about the “Indie Bloodbath,” I thought, “Here we go.” The dynamics of content distribution WILL change. The dynamics of spec sales WILL change. You must now build your own road to a screenwriting career. Personally, I think film is dead and the entire distribution system needs to be demolished and rebuilt from the ground up. How do you do that? Start a new movie chain that defies the rules? I don’t know. But these are sober times. Consider these tweets:

“It’s a massacre. It’s the end of funny money.” (http://bit.ly/12dE1N)

Charlie Kaufman: “It’s a disaster out there… I don’t think the mid-range movie is going to exist anymore.” (http://bit.ly/axfjQ)

“The American Indie business is a walking corpse” (http://bit.ly/fBTWH)

How To Survive The Current Indie Producer Hell: “Cut all your budgets by 60%” (http://bit.ly/cgxlM)

“The ways films were financed & sold for the last fifteen years are no longer do-able.” (http://bit.ly/19tgWX)

“Can the ‘Indie Bloodbath’ be traced to the decline of critics?” (http://bit.ly/12qpQa)

“Anything above a micro-budget level is going to have a hard time getting into theaters.” (http://bit.ly/8HSr9)

Ebert: “The bottom fell out of the market… a collapse of confidence in the prospects of [Indie] film distribution.” (http://bit.ly/YoRvr)

“There may be something more insidious at work. It’s possible there simply aren’t as many great movies being made.” (http://bit.ly/1cIYYz)

Peter Broderick’s 10 Principles of Hybrid Distribution (http://bit.ly/1a7OjL)

“The old model – making a film with investors, taking it to festivals, selling it there – is nearly gone” (http://bit.ly/1CaT4)

10 (9 actually) Responses to the Issues Brought Up at the “Indie Film Summit” (http://bit.ly/yNwMp)

SM: I recently started on Twitter, but being the pseudo-old fart that I am, I’m sure I’m doing everything wrong. So for me and any other Twitter neophytes out there, what advice can you give us so we stop making fools of ourselves in cyberspace.

MM: I’ve made a bigger fool of myself than anyone on Twitter, I think. When I first started, I tweeted too much, which pissed off my friends, and some quit following me. I’m trying not to do that anymore and tweet only the most essential articles. I also got hacked recently. Direct messages were being sent from me with links to phishing scams. Sigh I’d suggest you not click links sent to you in a direct message unless you trust the source. Even then, they could’ve been hacked like me. If you get hacked, change your password. You’ll have to wait some amount of time before Twitter will allow you to start following people again. You can also follow the Spam twitter account or the #spam thread.

SM: As a Certified Mystery Man Tweet Follower, I am amazed by how much great information about movies and screenwriting you manage to dig up. How the hell do you do it? Are you like glued to your computer keyboard or could that other rumor about your sweatshop of research slaves in Saipan be true?

MM: Are you kidding? I don’t have time to search for shit. It’s called Google Alerts. You should look into it. But I do have an assistant (she’s very much like Ulla from The Producers). Hehehe

SM: We all know that Kevin Smith, John August, and Diablo Cody Tweet. What other screenwriters can you recommend who share their wisdom with the world in 140 character thought bytes on Twitter?

MM: Only one person I ardently recommend for screenwriters – David Hudson. He’s the most obsessive compiler of film links of anyone in the world. He’s AMAZING.

SM: You’re a screenwriter, a columnist for Script magazine, an ex-blogger, and a Tweeter? Which one of those occupations fills you with the most pride and why?

MM: The reaction to my article on the Raiders Story Conference was probably the highest high of blogging. I was thinking, “Look at this! Mystery Man – MYSTERY MAN of all things – is in The New York Times!” “Look at this! Entertainment Weekly!” “Look at this! John August!” “Look at this! NBC Local News in Dallas!” And then it’s over and you’re back to work again.

My favorite article has to be the one I wrote on John Michael Hayes. I had just finished reading about him when he passed away. I couldn’t believe it. So I told his story and how he became a screenwriter. Get this. John Michael Hayes left his family, who never once supported his writing aspirations. He snuck away while his family was at the movies, no less. He hitchhiked his way across the country from Worcester, Massachusetts, all the way to Hollywood while hopping on two canes (recovering from a severe case of rheumatoid arthritis) and with only $15 in his pocket! Can you believe that? I wrote, “Yeah, all you aspiring writers out there think you have it so rough? Tell me you want to be a writer as badly as John Michael Hayes. Tell me you would’ve done what John Michael Hayes did.

So I posted the article, and his son, Garrett Michael Hayes, commented, “I’ve read a great number of the recent JMH obits and online mentions. Thus far, yours comes closest to capturing a sense of his life.” Then John’s daughter, Meredyth, wrote, “It made my heart full today to read this and I thank you.”

How can you surpass those highs?

I’ll tell you how. Screenwriting. Making films. Nothing beats it.

There you go, some insight, wisdom, and mojo links from Mystery Man. And be sure to check out MM’s 101 Best Articles.

If any of you have heard anything re Mystery Man, please share your thoughts in comments.

Godspeed, Mystery Man.

21 thoughts on “Mystery Man news

  1. This is very sad news. As trivial as it may seem, he was the first person I followed when I signed up for twitter and was thankfully my first follower.
    In fact, he and another screenwriting blogger were the reasons I signed up for the thing in the first place.
    I hope he went quietly into the night.
    Godspeed.
    Scott, thank you for sharing this news.

  2. I must say it didn't come entirely unexpectedly after exactly three months of complete radio silence. That had never happened since he started blogging back in 2006.

    Still I was pretty shocked when the email arrived.

    Such a generous man. I'm very grateful for all he has shared with us over the years. And he'll continue to do so via his book!

    Thank you Scott, for remembering MM this weekend.

  3. Mystery Man was one of the first blogs I ever read on screenwriting and was a big inspiration for me to start my own blog. He was a very insightful writer and his persona was full of intrigue. Like the first comment by James, I hope the report of his death—in Mark Twain style— is an elaborate hoax.

    One thing that makes me think it isn’t a hoax is I traded emails with Mystery Man back in March and on March 16 he agreed via email to write a guest post for me and then I never heard from him again. He’s just busy I thought. But even more so, he once told me he was going to write a book and give it away. So when you report that his assistant says that his screenwriting book will be available as a free download it seems consistent with his desires.

    In a day of $500 screenwriting seminars and even higher paid screenwriting consultants, Mystery Man’s approached to giving his knowledge away seemed unorthodox and generous. But unorthodox and generous sums up my experience with Mystery Man.

    Like the passing of Blake Snyder (Save the Cat), this news—if true—is blow to the screenwriting community. But like Snyder, Mystery Man left a wealth of information and inspiration that hopefully will improve the quality of storytelling for years to come.

    Scott W. Smith

  4. OH God!!

    My condolences to every dreaming and aspiring screenwriter. We lost a great mentor.

    MM

    Thanks for your great legacy.

  5. That's a shocker, if you haven't read his old blog and tweets your missing treat. I found Scott's site via MM and it has been a blessing.

    Thank you Mystery Man you will be missed.

  6. I don’t remember exactly how I connected with MM. I followed him and he followed me and I don’t know who did what first.

    I’m curious why people might think his death is a hoax? I guess because he won’t reveal his identity, we can’t know for sure that he’s passed. Well, I just answered my own question.

    However, like he says in Scott’s article here, he was a writing machine. I could barely keep up with his tweets. So I had to wonder what happened when his writing/tweeting came to a complete stop a few months back.
    Did he take off on a sudden and much needed vacay? Did he get bored? Does he suffer from hypergrafia?

    Maybe he thinks it’s time for us to fly on our own.

    I hope it isn’t true. Losing Blake Snyder so abruptly last year, and then this news today about MM on top of losing Hopper, McClanahan, and a dear friend of mine, a talented set dec/propsman, Scott “Scooter Magoo” Smith in the last week underscores that time and life are precious and reminds us that we have no idea how many people we can touch or inspire through our craft.

    Keep writing.

  7. He was inspiring. I found his posts always inspired me to think in deep and complex ways about film and screenwriting.

    Not to mention he was generous in spirit, kind, funny, and sweet.

    Simply one of my all-around favorite people I know – online or otherwise.

    I really looked forward to the day we'd meet over martinis.

  8. I don't know if I believe that the person behind MM is dead. I have a hunch that the persona passed away, not the person.

  9. I'm a great fan of MM – he was generous and kind in promoting me as well – but I fall into the camp of, "This sounds like the death of an identity, not a person."

    The issue of his identity still not being revealed seems odd to me. Until we know the details of his "passing away" I can't mourn him.

  10. Like all the others; I'll miss Mystery Man too. I really enjoyed reading his posts, and thought he was a cool cat.

    He'll be missed.

    - E.C. Henry from Bonney Lake, WA

  11. This is a shock. I loved his blog. He seemed to really love movies.

    Since it was mentioned that he hadn't finished his SWing book– very unlikely if the man was simply retiring an internet persona– I'm gonna assume the real person is gone.

    Very sad.

  12. Thanks for re-posting that interview, Scott. I also got the tragic letter from Rebekah, asking for the news to be passed. You were a smart blogger to get that interview while you had the chance. I meant to ask him for an interview, too, but never got around to it.

    I work with fiction authors, not screenwriters, but I can tell you Mystery Man was the first blogger I ever made a point of directing readers toward. He was my all-time favorite blogger on the craft of writing. I even wrote to him the day I discovered his site, saying he was the only blogger I'd ever found who could make me blow eight hours of my one day off reading his stuff, and he was absolutely charming in his response.

    Wherever he is, I hope he's looking down on us now, giving his signature, "hee hee!"

  13. Movie critic Roger Ebert prepares to write a memoir – CSMonitor.com
    May 26, 2010 … By Rebekah Denn / May 26, 2010. The first of 1282 comments on one of Roger Ebert's blog entries summed it up well: “Mr. Ebert, you may be a …

  14. A blow and a shock to the system to hear the terrible news.

    MMonFilm gave me inspiration and new perspectives about how the process of screen writing is achieved. And! I hope to continue to learn from MMonFilms writings. That is a legacy, if nothing else.

  15. Just catching up on screenwriting news. Wow, what a sad loss.

    My interaction w/ Mystery Man was virtual. Even so, he was always gracious and responsive.

    I really hope his blog and website stays up for people to continue to use as a resource.

  16. Mystery Man didn't die. The person behind him was/is David Hayes who is alive and well. An elaborate hoax and a very poor way to end a relationship with a lot of fans.

  17. Pingback: Bayswater Rendering

  18. Pingback: C128 Cat Grass 125 Grams

Leave a Reply